Spotify 'not well-run' operationally despite bullish podcast sentiment, says analyst

·Senior Reporter

June 9, 2022 at 4:52 PM·3 min read

Spotify (SPOT) is all in on podcasts — but questions still loom over the audio giant's fundamentals.

"Spotify is clearly the leader in the podcast space," CFRA analyst John Freeman told Yahoo Finance, noting that although the company's future potential "is amazing," the platform is "not well-run in the operational aspects."

Freeman listed several fundamental concerns, including issues surrounding the company's software and interface, as well as an inability to turn profits and what he describes as a "sloppy handling" of the Joe Rogan podcast controversy earlier this year.

"Those kinds of things make me have a neutral to almost semi-negative fundamental view, relative to the potential," the analyst said.

Investors seem to have similar concerns with shares tumbling by more than 50% so far in 2022 and by 70% since reaching an all-time high in February 2021.

But shares jumped over 6% in midday trading on Wednesday after the company revealed during its investor day that it brought in roughly $215 million in podcast revenue last year.

Spotify's chief content and advertising business officer Dawn Ostroff told investors that the audio giant is still in "investment mode" after spending a whopping $1 billion on its podcast unit so far; yet, she expects the business to be a "$20 billion opportunity" with continued improvements in both ad products and monetization.

The problem is not [Spotify's] gross margin line, it's the operating margin line...John Freeman, CFRA Analyst

CEO Daniel Ek also underscored the potential of the platform's podcast unit, estimating that he expects it to generate margins between 40% to 50%.

That margin call seems to have been the catalyst for Wednesday's stock surge, but Freeman said "the problem is not the gross margin line, it's the operating margin line."

In April, Spotify issued quarterly gross margin guidance that fell short of Wall Street's estimates, in part due to its spending on non-music content.

Spotify "has been a public company for a while, and they've really never been profitable," he continued, signaling that the platform's sky-high costs for its podcast deals (which included a reported $200 million multi-year licensing contract with Joe Rogan) can only go so far.

"The problem with paying Joe Rogan, or whoever, a lot of money is that you lose leverage on a certain percentage of your subscriber base and it then becomes the 'Joe Rogan show,'" the analyst explained.

He added, "I have no problem with them sacrificing growth — if they can show some profitability."

The Joe Rogan Experience is one of the most successful podcasts on Spotify's platform (Dado Ruvic / reuters)

Despite the costly endeavor, Freeman noted that there is still "growth on the advertising side," although it will take some time to fully mature.

U.S. podcast advertising revenues rose to $1.4 billion in 2021, surpassing the $1 billion mark for the first time, according to a study from the Interactive Advertising Bureau. The bureau predicted that the market will exceed $2 billion in 2022 with an estimate of over $4 billion by the year 2024.

Overall, CFRA's Freeman maintains a strong Buy rating on the stock, citing it as a "shorter term, valuation-based trade."

He advised the company to continue to focus on podcasts (he's particularly bearish on the audiobook component of the business), explaining that continued growth overseas will be an important profitability element moving forward.

On Thursday, Bank of America reiterated its Buy rating on the stock, raising its price target to $164 a share (up from $137.)

Raymond James, meanwhile, upped its outlook earlier this week — upgrading shares to Outperform from Market Perform and offering a price target of $150 per share.

Alexandra is a Senior Entertainment and Food Reporter at Yahoo Finance. Follow her on Twitter @alliecanal8193 and email her at alexandra.canal@yahoofinance.com

Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, LinkedIn, and YouTube

Click here for the latest trending stock tickers of the Yahoo Finance platform

Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance

Download the Yahoo Finance app for Apple or Android

Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, LinkedIn, and YouTube

Reuters
Indonesia to permanently relocate 10,000 people after Ruang volcano eruptions
The Indonesian government will permanently relocate almost 10,000 residents after a series of explosive eruptions of the Ruang volcano has raised concerns about the dangers of residing on the island in future, a minister said on Friday. About 9,800 people live on Ruang island, in the province of North Sulawesi, but in recent weeks all residents have been forced to evacuate after the mountain has continued to spew incandescent lava and columns of ash kilometres into the sky. Authorities this week raised the alert status of the volcano to the highest level, closed the provincial airport in Manado, and also warned of the a possible tsunami if parts of the mountain collapse into the surrounding waters.
8m ago
Associated Press
Panama Supreme Court rejects challenge to candidacy of presidential frontrunner days before vote
Panama’s Supreme Court rejected a constitutional challenge to the candidacy of leading presidential contender José Raúl Mulino on Friday, removing an element of uncertainty two days before the May 5 vote. The court was ruling on a challenge from lawyer Karisma Etienne Karamañites, who argued that Mulino was not eligible because he had not been selected through a primary by the Achieving Goals party of former president Ricardo Martinelli. Panama’s Electoral Tribunal in March barred Martinelli from standing, cutting short his attempted political revival, because he had been sentenced to more than 10 years in prison for money laundering.
10m ago
AFP
China launches first probe to collect samples from far side of Moon
China launched a probe on Friday to collect samples from the far side of the Moon, a world first as Beijing pushes ahead with an ambitious programme that aims to send a crewed lunar mission by 2030.China aims to send a crewed mission to the Moon by 2030 and plans to build a base on the lunar surface.
14m ago
Reuters
Novo Nordisk drops 5% after rival Amgen teases weight-loss drug data
Novo Nordisk were last down 4.4% by 1022 GMT, having hit their lowest in two months earlier in the day. Amgen on Thursday said it was very encouraged after completing an interim analysis of its mid-stage study of experimental weight-loss drug MariTide, which, if approved, would compete Novo's Wegovy and Eli Lilly's Zepbound. "Novo's share price today is certainly factoring in some negative reaction to Amgen's positive commentary on MariTide development yesterday," Kepler Cheuvreux analyst David Evans said, but added that "a continued negative reaction to results and pricing concerns yesterday is likely also a smaller part of the move today".
14m ago
Associated Press
Former UK prime minister Boris Johnson turned away from polling station after forgetting photo ID
Former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson was turned away from a polling station after forgetting to bring ID to vote in the U.K.'s local elections. British media reported Friday that Johnson — who introduced the requirement for voters to provide ID with a photo when he was in office — was told by polling station staff in South Oxfordshire Thursday that he would not be able to vote without proving his identity. Sky News reported that Johnson, who served as Conservative prime minister from 2019 to 2022, was later able to cast his ballot and that he voted Conservative.
15m ago
AFP
Kenya floods death toll tops 200 as cyclone approaches
The death toll from flood-related incidents in Kenya has crossed 200 since March, the interior ministry said Friday, as a cyclone barrelled towards the Tanzanian coast.Kenya's interior ministry forecast that the cyclone was likely to "bring strong winds and large ocean waves, with heavy rainfall" expected to hit the coast starting Sunday.
16m ago
Reuters
Ban on Russian uranium helps US build nuclear fuel capacity, official says
The U.S. has been preparing since 2022 for the possibility that Russian President Vladimir Putin would stop selling it nuclear power fuel, and a pending ban on Russian imports will help boost domestic capacity to process uranium fuel, the outgoing top nuclear energy official told Reuters. The U.S. Senate passed legislation on Tuesday that bans the imports from Russia, the latest move by Washington to disrupt Putin's ability to pay for the full-scale invasion of Ukraine that began in 2022. The ban, which is expected to be signed by President Joe Biden, starts 90 days after enactment, although it allows the Department of Energy to issue waivers in case of supply concerns.
16m ago
AFP
Police clear pro-Gaza sit-in at top Paris university
Police entered Paris' Sciences Po university on Friday to remove dozens of students staging a pro-Gaza sit-in in the entrance hall, AFP journalists saw, as protests fire political debate about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.Protesters occupied the entrance hall in a "peaceful sit-in" following a debate on the Middle East with administrators on Thursday morning that their Palestine Committee dubbed "disappointing".
20m ago
Associated Press
Yellen says threats to democracy risk US economic growth, an indirect jab at Trump
Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen is arguing that a fractured democracy can have destructive effects on the economy — an indirect jab at Donald Trump. Yellen, in an address prepared for delivery Friday in Arizona, uses economic data to paint a picture of how disregard for America's democratic processes and institutions can cause economic stagnation for decades. Yellen, taking a rare step toward to the political arena, never mentions Trump, the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, by name in her speech for the McCain Institute's Sedona Forum, but she hints at the former president's potential impact if he regains the White House.
21m ago
Associated Press
The Latest | Trump's hush money trial enters 11th day as second week of testimony is set to wrap up
Donald Trump will return to Manhattan court on Friday as his hush money trial enters its 11th day, capping a frenzied second week of witness testimony. Lawyer Keith Davidson concluded his testimony Thursday after spending nearly 6 1/2 hours on the stand over two days. Thursday's proceedings included a contempt hearing over whether the former president had again violated his gag order.
23m ago
Associated Press
China dispatches vice premier, urges better safety measures after highway collapse killed 48
China has sent a vice premier to oversee recovery efforts and urged better safety measures after a highway collapse killed at least 48 people in the country’s mountainous south. The official Xinhua News Agency on Friday said Vice Premier Zhang Guoqing had “stressed sparing no effort in carrying out rescue and relief work.” The dispatch of Zhang, who is also a member of one of the ruling Communist Party's leading bodies, illustrates the concern over a possible public backlash over the disaster, the latest in a series of deadly infrastructure failures.
29m ago
Reuters
Portugal's government fears road tolls defeat heralds political paralysis
Portugal's new centre-right minority government has suffered its first setback in parliament as the far-right Chega party teamed up with the Socialists to end toll payments on eight motorways, imposing an unwanted increase in public spending. The government fears Thursday's vote may be the start of political forces from the opposite ends of the spectrum working together to paralyse activity and force another election. A coalition led by the centre-right Social Democratic Party (PSD) won the March 10 election by a slim margin over the centre-left Socialist Party (PS), and the populist, anti-immigration Chega quadrupled its seats in the most fragmented parliament in 50 years of democracy.
36m ago
Associated Press
2 Nigerian military personnel will face court martial over a drone attack that killed 85 villagers
Two Nigerian military personnel will face a court martial over the killing of 85 villagers in a military drone attack in December in the West African nation’s conflict-battered north, authorities said, prompting calls from a rights group Friday for more transparency and justice for victims. The two personnel will be subjected to military justice proceedings “for acts of omission or commission” after investigations found that the civilians killed by the strike “were mistaken for terrorists,” Nigeria’s Defense Headquarters spokesperson Maj. Gen. Edward Buba said in a statement Thursday without providing further details. Nigeria’s military often conducts air raids as it fights the extremist violence and rebel attacks that have destabilized Nigeria’s northern region for more than a decade, often leaving civilian casualties in its wake.
42m ago
Reuters
Top US Treasury official to travel to Singapore, Malaysia to discuss sanctions
The U.S. Treasury Department's top sanctions official will travel to Singapore and Malaysia next week, a source familiar with the matter told Reuters, as Washington seeks to combat funding for Iran and its proxy groups as well as evasion of its sanctions on Russia. The source, speaking on condition of anonymity, said there has been an uptick in money moving to Iran and its proxies, including Hamas, through the Malaysian financial system. During the visit, first reported by Reuters, Treasury's under secretary for terrorism and financial intelligence, Brian Nelson, is expected to discuss U.S. concerns and the sanctions risk such activity poses, the source said.
45m ago
Reuters
Boeing sending first astronaut crew to space after years of delay
Boeing is poised to send the first Starliner space capsule with a crew of humans into orbit next week, giving it a long-delayed chance to score a badly needed win as it struggles to compete with Elon Musk's SpaceX. The CST-100 Starliner test mission, a years-delayed milestone after more than $1 billion in cost overruns, will ferry two NASA astronauts to the International Space Station (ISS) in a final demonstration before the spacecraft can be approved to fly routine space trips under the space agency's commercial crew program. NASA in recent years has backed a new generation of privately built spacecraft that can ferry its astronauts and other customers to the ISS and, under its more ambitious Artemis program, to the moon and eventually Mars.
45m ago
CNN
How to buy your first luxury watch
Thinking about buying your first luxury timepiece? Here’s what experts say you need to know before making the purchase
48m ago
Yahoo Finance
Peloton shows everything doesn't need to be a subscription: Morning Brief
Peloton isn't profitable as a subscription business, but it looks different as a media company.
51m ago
Reuters
Russian cyber attacks targeted defence, aerospace sectors, Berlin says
A series of cyber attacks attributable to the Russian military intelligence service GRU targeted Germany's governing Social Democrats as well as the country's logistics, defence, aerospace and IT sectors, the interior ministry said on Friday. "The Russian cyber attacks are a threat to our democracy, which we are resolutely countering," Interior Minister Nancy Faeser said in a statement, adding that Germany was acting alongside the EU and NATO. Faeser added that it was particularly critical to counter such attacks from Russia ahead of the European and other elections this year.
51m ago
Associated Press
Nippon Steel delays closing of acquisition of US Steel until late this year after US DOJ request
Nippon Steel said Friday it has postponed the expected closing of its $14.1 billion takeover of U.S. Steel by three months after the U.S. Department of Justice requested more documentation related to the deal. Tokyo-based Nippon Steel Corp. said the deal, already approved by U.S. Steel's shareholders, is still expected to go through. “Nippon Steel will continue to fully cooperate with the examination of the relevant authorities,” it said in a statement.
55m ago
Associated Press
Flowers, candles, silence as Serbia marks the 1st anniversary of mass shooting at a Belgrade school
Hundreds of people laid flowers and lit candles on Friday to commemorate the victims of Serbia's first-ever school shooting a year ago that left nine children and a school guard dead and six people wounded. A somber, silent queue formed on a rainy day outside the Vladislav Ribnikar Elementary School in central Belgrade where a 13-year-old boy is accused of opening fire at his schoolmates with his father's guns last year. The shooting stunned Serbia.
55m ago

Latest Stories