Are Parent PLUS loans eligible for forgiveness? No, but there's still a loophole to save

Medora Lee, USA TODAY

February 29, 2024 at 11:05 AM·4 min read

Parents who took federal loans to pay for their kid’s college education can use a loophole to cut their monthly repayments, student loan experts say.

When President Joe Biden announced plans to provide relief to the more than 40 million Americans with federal loans, he excluded these so-called Parent PLUS Loans from the most lucrative income-driven repayment (IDR) plans. There are 3.8 million Parent PLUS borrowers, and they're disproportionately Black and Latino. And they're only eligible for the Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) plan, which has higher monthly payments than the other plans.

The only way parents can access one of the more money-saving IDR plans is through a loophole, but they must act fast. The Department of Education knows the loophole exists and plans to close it July 1, 2025.

What is the ICR plan?

The ICR plan is always available for Parent PLUS Loan holders:

Payments under the ICR plan are always based on your income and family size. It’s the lesser of:

Twenty percent of your discretionary income.
Fixed payments over 12 years, adjusted according to your income.

Note: In some cases, your payment can be higher than the amount you would have to pay under the 10-year Standard Repayment Plan, the Department of Education warns.

◾ Repayment length: 25 years.

◾ Parent PLUS loans must be consolidated into a direct loan to be eligible.

Buried under student loan debt: Some who took out parent PLUS loans to send their kids to college expect to die with debt

How ICR compares with other repayment plans?

◾ All other plans produce lower monthly payments because they are based on a lower percentage of your income and usually have lower interest rates. Payments are capped at between 10% and 20% of your discretionary income. Under the new SAVE plan, for example, more of your income is also protected from student loan payments and the payment cap will be cut in July to 5% for undergraduate loans.

Say you earn $50,000 annually and have $100,000 of Parent PLUS loans. The ICR monthly payment would be $590, while the SAVE plan would be only $143, according to Student Loan Planner, which helps people manage student debt.

◾ Some plans also have shorter repayment periods. and remaining loan balances are forgiven after 20 or 25 years of payments. If you're eligible for Public Service Loan Forgiveness, you can get your remaining debt forgiven after just 10 years in an income-driven plan.

◾ The new SAVE plan also has an interest benefit. If you make your monthly payment, your loan balance won’t grow due to unpaid interest that accrued since your last payment.

How can Parent PLUS Loan holders get a better repayment plan?

It’s time-consuming, complicated and requires a careful double consolidation of loans by July 1, 2025, to access the most lucrative SAVE plan.

First, parents must have more than one PLUS loan. “You can only benefit if you have more than one,” said Stacy MacPhetres, senior director of education finance at EdAssist by Bright Horizons, a provider of educational advisory services to organizations and families. If that's your situation, experts say do the following:

Initiate the first consolidation process on paper for your existing Parent PLUS loans so they’re with two different servicers and choose the ICR plan. You must do this on paper and mail it because you’ll only be allowed to do one online consolidation, which comes next. Approval can take up to 90 days.

Once you receive confirmation those loans have been consolidated, you have to consolidate again. You consolidate those loans together online with one, new servicer. The new servicer will no longer be able to see that the original loans were Parent PLUS loans and you’ll be able to sign up for an IDR plan with lower payments, MacPhetres said.

If you can get all of this done by April 30, the government will adjust payment counts for the consolidated loans to start from your very first payment, which could bring you closer to forgiveness.

If you’re just starting the consolidation process now, it’s unlikely you’ll finish by April 30, but that shouldn’t deter you. “You’ll still get credit, just not the full credit,” MacPhetres said. “They’ll do a weighted average.”

For example, if you have a loan that’s been in repayment for three years and another for four, you can get 3.5 years of payments counted toward your forgiveness, she said.

The cap of a University of Iowa graduate reads "Cancel student debt" during a commencement ceremony for the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, Saturday, May 14, 2022, at Carver-Hawkeye Arena in Iowa City, Iowa.

220514 Ui Commencement 020 Jpg — The cap of a University of Iowa graduate reads "Cancel student debt" during a commencement ceremony for the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, Saturday, May 14, 2022, at Carver-Hawkeye Arena in Iowa City, Iowa. 220514 Ui Commencement 020 Jpg

How many people can benefit from the loophole?

Parent PLUS borrowers owe more than $112 billion, accounting for 13% of the total outstanding federal student loan debt, according to Senator Chris Van Hollen, who has called on the Biden administration to expand student debt relief to cover these borrowers.

Medora Lee is a money, markets, and personal finance reporter at USA TODAY. You can reach her at mjlee@usatoday.com and subscribe to our free Daily Money newsletter for personal finance tips and business news every Monday through Friday.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Income driven repayment plan for Parent PLUS loans has hack for saving

Associated Press
Storms battering the Midwest bring tornadoes, hail and strong winds
Severe storms barreled through the Midwest, unleashing a curtain of heavy rain, gusty winds and tornadoes throughout the region that forecasters warned could stretch into Wednesday morning. Tornadoes were spotted after dark Tuesday in parts of Michigan, Indiana and Ohio. Portions of Illinois, Kentucky and Missouri were also under a tornado watch, according to the National Weather Service.
AFP
Milking venom from Australia's deadly marine animals
Imagine feeling like an elephant is sitting on your chest, you can't breathe, there's a sense of impending doom and the pain is so intense you want to die.If its spines pierce your skin, the pain will cause you to lose consciousness and the area around the wound will turn black and die.
Associated Press
Western Hemisphere nations pledge to continue coordinating response to historic regional migration
Representatives from 22 Western Hemisphere countries gathered in Guatemala renewed their commitment Tuesday to continue offering legal pathways to enter their countries, to provide aid to communities most affected by migration and to coordinate their response to manage immigration flows. U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken noted that progress had been made in all of those areas during the past two years. Two years ago, leaders from across the hemisphere signed the “Los Angeles Declaration,” a U.S.-led attempt to coordinate a regional response to historic levels of migration.
Associated Press
Grit, humor, grief and gloom mix as Ukrainians face a dangerous new phase in the war
Paintbrush in hand, Anastasiya Sereda is working on a painting of a chubby-faced panda in the uniform of a Ukrainian soldier. Propped on her easel is the reason why – a photo of her boyfriend Bohdan, a burly serviceman with a gentle smile. “He looks like a panda,” Sereda said in explanation, alternately laughing and choking with tears as she talked about her partner, who was killed almost a year ago on the front line in eastern Ukraine.
Associated Press
House Republicans will turn to K-12 schools in latest antisemitism probe
The leaders of three large public school systems will appear before Congress on Wednesday to answer questions about how they have handled incidents of antisemitism on their school campuses. The witnesses scheduled to testify before a House Education and Workforce subcommittee represent New York City Public Schools, the Berkeley Unified School District in California and the Montgomery County Public Schools in Maryland.
Associated Press
Albanese rejects China's argument that Australia was at fault for dangerous aircraft encounter
China's account blaming Australia for a dangerous clash between their military aircraft in international airspace over the Yellow Sea failed to undermine Australian objections, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said Wednesday. The Chinese and Australians lodged official protests and blamed each other for a Chinese warplane’s extraordinary use of flares against an Australian navy helicopter Saturday. Australia publicly accused China of unprofessional and unacceptable behavior, while China retorted that the Seahawk deliberately flew close to China’s airspace in a “provocative move.”
Associated Press
Trump in no hurry as he leans into the pageantry of vice presidential tryouts
As former President Donald Trump remains stuck in the courtroom listening to salacious details of an affair he denies, another spectacle is playing out in the background as his vice presidential tryouts get underway. Trump, at one point, invited many of the contenders on stage like contestants in one of his old beauty pageants. The next day several of them, including South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott, South Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum, Ohio Sen. Marco Rubio and New York Rep. Elise Stefanik, fanned out across Sunday news shows to sing his praises.
Associated Press
Future of MLB's Tampa Bay Rays to come into focus with key meetings on $1.3B stadium project
The future of the Tampa Bay Rays is about to come into clearer focus as local officials begin public discussions over a planned $1.3 billion ballpark that would be the anchor of a much larger project to transform downtown St. Petersburg with affordable housing, a Black history museum, a hotel and office and retail space. The St. Petersburg City Council will begin a detailed look Thursday at the plans by the Rays and the Hines development company for what the city calls the Historic Gas Plant Project. The name is a nod to the 86-acre (34-hectare) tract's history as a once-thriving Black community demolished for the Rays' current domed Tropicana Field and earlier for an interstate highway spur.
Associated Press
Can you afford to take care of your children and parents? Biden revives effort to lower costs
As President Joe Biden runs for reelection, he’s resurrecting proposals to reshape American life from the cradle to the grave by lowering the cost of child care, expanding preschool opportunities and making home aides more available to the elderly. The initiatives were once part of Build Back Better, Biden’s gargantuan legislative agenda that stalled on Capitol Hill two years ago. Now they’re what Neera Tanden, the Democratic president's top domestic policy adviser, describes as “unfinished business.”
AFP
US halts bomb shipment to Israel over Rafah concerns
The United States paused a shipment of bombs to Israel last week over fears it would invade the southern Gaza city of Rafah, an official said Tuesday, marking the first time in the conflict that President Joe Biden has squeezed military aid to the key US ally.The pausing of weapons marks the first time that Biden has acted on the warning that he gave Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in April that US policy on Gaza would depend on how Israel treated civilians.
Associated Press
Has Israel followed the law in its war in Gaza? The US is due to render a first-of-its-kind verdict
Facing heat over its military support for Israel's war, the Biden administration is due to deliver a first-of-its-kind formal verdict this week on whether the airstrikes on Gaza and restrictions on delivery of aid have violated international and U.S. laws designed to spare civilians from the worst horrors of war. A decision against Israel would add to pressure on President Joe Biden to curb the flow of weapons and money to Israel's military. The administration agreed in February at the insistence of Democrats in Congress to look at whether Israel has used U.S.-provided weapons and other military assistance in a lawful manner.
CNN
A high-stakes report looms over Biden on whether Israel violated international law
The Biden administration is rushing to finish a high-stakes report due to Congress this week on whether Israel has violated international humanitarian law during its war in Gaza— a determination that could lead to significant repercussions and further inflame divisions at home and abroad.
CNN
The Trump hush money trial might be tawdry but it’s likely the only one he’ll face before the election
“The People Call Stormy Daniels.”
Associated Press
Italy's president says Russia's invasion of Ukraine can't be solved by rewarding Moscow's aggression
Italy’s president told the U.N. General Assembly on Tuesday that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine can’t be solved by rewarding its aggression and peace can only come when Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity are restored. Sergio Mattarella said Italy, which now heads the G7 meetings, and many international partners have come to Ukraine’s defense to support the principle that solidarity must be given to nations attacked by acts that violate international law and the U.N. Charter.
AFP
Global car giants seek tech allies in China's cutthroat EV market
Struggling foreign automakers in China are looking for help from local tech giants to try to stay competitive in the world's biggest electric car market, where shiny smart screens, assisted driving and sophisticated map technology are in high demand.One major reason why foreign automakers are seeking partnerships with local tech firms is to benefit from their innovation, which Chinese automaking executives have attributed to the cutthroat competition in the industry.
Politico
Unexpected warning signs for Trump in busy Indiana primary
There were a half-dozen consequential GOP primaries Tuesday, but Nikki Haley’s performance in the already concluded presidential race could be a sign of trouble for Trump in more competitive states.
CNN
Judge said he won’t tolerate Trump’s cursing and headshaking during Daniels’ testimony, transcript shows
The judge in Donald Trump’s hush money trial called the former president’s defense attorney to the bench and ordered him to speak to his client about his “contemptuous” behavior during adult film actress Stormy Daniels’ testimony Tuesday, according to the trial transcript.
NBC News
Arizona State scholar on leave after video of verbal attack on woman in hijab goes viral
An Arizona State University postdoctoral research scholar is on leave as the institution investigates his confrontation with a woman in a hijab that was captured on video, the school said Tuesday.
CNN
Super-aged Japan now has 9 million vacant homes. And that’s a problem
The number of vacant houses in Japan has surged to a record high of nine million – more than enough for each person in New York City – as the east Asian country continues to struggle with its ever-declining population.
CNN
Several tornadoes hit Michigan, where 12 people were hurt in one mobile home park in southern part of the state
Several tornadoes hit Michigan on Tuesday, with one twister pummeling a mobile home park in the southern part of the state, leaving a dozen people hurt and rescuers looking for more possible victims.

What is the ICR plan?

How ICR compares with other repayment plans?

How can Parent PLUS Loan holders get a better repayment plan?

How many people can benefit from the loophole?

Latest Stories